Skip to content

Four one-bedroom stays in St. Augustine, compared

St. George Street in St. Augustine's Historic District on a clear afternoon, with pedestrians walking between two-story colonial buildings

There are four one-bedroom places in our St. Augustine inventory, and they split cleanly: three sit in the Historic District where you'll park once and walk everywhere, and one sits out on the water with a pool, tennis courts and a thirty-day minimum. Which you want depends almost entirely on whether you intend to use a car.

Here they are, plainly:

There's a fifth worth knowing about if the first four are taken: Suite Three at Pomar House, also one bedroom, also on Cuna Street, sleeping three. Same building, same coded entry, same walk to everything.

The suite that puts you on St. George Street itself

The Balcony Suite is the only one of these where the address is the amenity. You're on St. George Street, with the Oldest Wooden School House and the City Gates right there, and the balcony looks down on the street itself. Live music carries up in the evening. That's a feature or a bug depending on what you came for, and most guests seem to come for exactly that: it has more reviews than any other one-bedroom we manage, and the rating sits just under a perfect ten.

Two things make it unusually practical for a downtown stay. First, your rate includes a parking permit for the Tolomato lot at 7 Cordova Street, which solves the single most annoying problem of staying in the old city. Second, there's an oversized desk in the window overlooking the street, which is the sort of detail that turns a weekend into a week for anyone working remotely. Long-term stays are allowed here.

The suite is on the second floor, up a staircase on the side of the building, with a king bed, a mini fridge and a microwave rather than a full kitchen. Fine for coffee, breakfast and a glass of wine on the balcony. Less good if you planned to cook dinner.

Cuna Street, one block off the noise

Pomar House sits on Cuna Street, a short walk from the Plaza and St. George Street, which means you get the same walkability with the crowd noise one block away. Both one-bedroom suites there are Spanish-style apartments, recently renovated, on the second floor behind a coded door.

Suite Two is the straightforward couples' apartment: king bed, smart TV, kitchenette with a mini fridge, microwave and coffee maker, and a washer and dryer in the unit. Two people, one bathroom, no negotiation over who gets the sofa.

Suite Four is nearly the same apartment with a sofa bed added in the main bedroom, so it sleeps three. Worth knowing before you book: the third sleeper is in the same room, not a separate one. For a couple travelling with an adult child or a friend who genuinely doesn't mind, it works. For three people who want their own space, it doesn't.

The Modern Rose occupies the ground floor of the building. Mention to the staff that you're staying upstairs and your coffee is free with any food order. It's a small thing that quietly decides where you eat breakfast for the whole stay.

Neither Cuna Street suite comes with parking at the building. There's a driveway for unloading bags, and the Historic Downtown Parking Facility is two blocks away at 1 Cordova Street, subject to availability. If arriving with a car and knowing exactly where it goes matters to you, the St. George suite's included permit is the cleaner answer.

The water option, and why it's a month minimum

The island townhouse is a different kind of trip altogether. It looks out over marsh and the Intracoastal Waterway, it's pet-friendly, kayaks are available, and the complex has a pool and tennis courts. It's also a minimum thirty-day rental, which tells you who it's for: snowbirds, people working remotely through a Florida winter, anyone between houses.

Inside it's a proper home rather than a suite. Full kitchen with a stove and oven, dining table, dedicated workspace, king bed with a fold-out sofa in the living room, and a bathtub. Laundry is in the complex rather than the unit. The HOA requires rental registration and background checks on guests, which we'll walk you through once you've booked, so build a little lead time into your plans.

From here you're minutes from both the beach and the old town, though any drive between the Historic District and the Anastasia Island beaches runs through the Bridge of Lions. Normally that's a ten to fifteen minute trip. On a July Saturday with the bridge up, it isn't.

If you're coming for the history, stay downtown

Castillo de San Marcos, the Colonial Quarter, the Oldest Wooden School House and the length of St. George Street are all within an easy walk of both Cuna Street and the St. George suite. That's the real argument for a downtown one-bedroom: the old city is small, the parking is the hard part, and solving parking once at the start of your stay changes the shape of every day after it.

If you want more than the colonial core, the seawall path along Matanzas Bay starts near the Bridge of Lions and runs about a mile and a half towards Francis Field, which is a pleasant early-morning walk from either Cuna Street or St. George. Anastasia State Park is a mile and a half from downtown, open daily from eight until sundown, with a four-mile stretch of beach and a short marsh trail through the dunes near Salt Run. Fort Matanzas is further south and needs a car.

Nights of Lights, and why a one-bedroom downtown is the right call

Nights of Lights runs every evening from 21 November 2026 through 18 January 2027, with millions of white lights over the historic downtown, and the Regatta of Lights on the second Saturday of December. The lights are best on foot, and the traffic in and out of downtown during the season is the reason people book Cuna Street. Suite Four is named for it. Park at 1 Cordova Street, leave the car there, and walk out into it every evening.

Book early for this one. Downtown one-bedrooms go first for the season, and there are only a handful of them in our inventory to begin with.

A quick way to choose

Note that the three downtown apartments are all on second floors reached by stairs, and all three are pet-free. The townhouse welcomes pets.

Booking with us

We're locally owned and independently operated, and have been for over twenty years. Every home gets a quality inspection and hotel-grade cleaning between guests, and there's guest support around the clock if something goes wrong at eleven at night. Rates and availability shift by season, so check dates directly for the home you want.

If you're torn between two of these, tell us what you're doing with your days. The choice between Cuna Street and the water is usually settled in one sentence.

Frequently asked questions